pan-european assessment, monitoring, and mitigation of stressors on the health of bees
New ecotoxicological research investigates the effects of glyphosate on bumble bees
No evidence that Glyphosate alone, or in combination with a common parasite, has negative lethal or sublethal effects on bumble bees
Glyphosate is the most commonly used pesticide in the world, and is widely used in agriculture. While glyphosate has been deemed ‘bee-safe’ by regulators, some emerging evidence studies suggest that it has negative effects on bees. For that reason, discovering whether glyphosate alone, or in combination with other stressors, is detrimental to bee health, has become a question of great importance.
A new study by authors Edward Straw and Prof. Mark Brown of Royal Holloway University of London (RHUL) expands the current knowledge on glyphosate. It examines the impact of glyphosate on a previously untested species, the buff-tailed bumble bee, Bombus terrestris, and incorporates a bee parasite, Crithidia bombi, that has never before been tested alongside glyphosate.
By using several different research methods from the field of ecotoxicology, the authors observed that there was no significant effect on bee mortality when bees were exposed to glyphosate, the bee parasite, or both stressors together. In addition, no significant effect was observed for reproduction or sucrose consumption.
The findings provide solid evidence that oral exposure to glyphosate does not cause mortality in bumble bees. Inconclusive evidence was found as to whether glyphosate made parasite infections more intense, but either way this is unlikely to be relevant at environmentally realistic concentrations.
Because the research finds no effects of glyphosate, the parasite, or their combination on any measurement of health, the results do not indicate any requirement to change the regulatory status of the active ingredient glyphosate as it pertains to bumble bees.
Despite the fact that the results find that glyphosate is unlikely to be harmful to bumble bees either alone, or alongside a common parasite, previous work found that it may have a negative impact on honey bees. For that reason, the authors of the article advise that further research on wild bee species and sublethal metrics would be useful to assist in resolving whether this widely used chemical is safe for bees.
Edward Straw says "Glyphosate is a very polarising chemical, with scientists divided over whether it’s safe or not. As such, it’s important that decisions about whether to restrict its usage are made based on rigorous science. Our findings are strong evidence that glyphosate alone is not causing mortality in bumble bees."
"As an incredibly important and useful pesticide we need more evidence from a wider range of species, exposures, and methodologies to determine if glyphosate is safe, so it can be used with confidence. Tests on the active ingredient (glyphosate) alone aren’t enough because prior work has found the other ingredients used in the pesticide products can be dangerous to bees."
This study is conducted within the framework of the EU Horizon 2020 research project PoshBee (grant agreement No. 773921).
Straw EA, Brown MJF. (2021). No evidence of effects or interaction between the widely used herbicide, glyphosate, and a common parasite in bumble bees. PeerJ 9:e12486 http://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.12486
This article is also available as a press release in EurekAlert! and AlphaGalileo.